I know you might not like this answer but ebay most car car parts there are decent. I have bought alot off ebay from the stores and never had a prob with car parts.If you are willing to get a used one. I found some good stuff here
http://car-part.com/. Should be able to just go by a junk yard and pick it up without pulling it off. They should do it for you. You could even find the same color.