Jesse,
Since manual transmissions have three pedals as opposed to the two pedal set-up that automatic cars have, the floor mat may be designed to accommodate the additional pedal found in a manual-equipped car. The automatic floor mat might fit but some modifications may be necessary in order to make this possible.
I know that the OEM all-weather floor mats are supposed to be pretty rugged and durable. I would shop around for the best price on these floor mats (OEM part # PT908-02090-02)
Cheers!
www.toyotapartszone.com